While many welcomed his election, MAGA supporters criticized his progressive views, labeling him “woke” and attacking past comments on immigration and racial justice. Prominent voices on the right accused him of being anti-Trump and too liberal for the papacy.

Despite the backlash, President Trump congratulated Pope Leo XIV, calling it a “great honor” for the U.S. The new Pope now begins a historic papacy that blends traditional faith with a modern, inclusive outlook.